“我是艾滋我怕谁” 艾滋病人敲诈擦鞋匠被杀
2009年03月19日 14:10南方网  
相关标签：  [艾滋病] 
管利鸿借自已是艾滋病人的身份，在街坊中四处敲诈。

他连贫困的擦鞋匠邱福生也不放过，屡次以“不给钱，就杀人”威胁。连民警也怕了他，不敢关他，却被他追着跑。

这更使管利鸿无所忌惮，在武力威胁邱福生时，反被邱福生夺刀砍死。

这就是震惊沈阳的擦鞋匠怒剁艾滋患者案。当地多家媒体称之为“一起都是被害人的庭审”，“事关社会正义，事关国家对艾滋病人犯罪的态度”。

在一个不足20平米的擦鞋店里，邱福生5分钟内狂砍艾滋病人管利鸿24刀，被控故意杀人罪一案，于3月16日上午在沈阳市中院第九审判庭开审。

庭审即将结束，杀人者邱福生缓慢起身，向死者家属浅鞠一躬:“希望你们能理解。”

死者管利鸿的姐姐管利萍无法理解眼前的杀人者，她用极端的口吻向南方周末记者表达自己的愤怒:“他（如果）杀人不偿命，我们就杀了他。”

这就是震惊沈阳的擦鞋匠怒剁艾滋患者案。当地多家媒体称之为“一起都是被害人的庭审”，“事关社会正义，事关国家对艾滋病人犯罪的态度”。

“擦错鞋油……错得要命”

管利鸿因寻衅敲诈未得到满足，就把邱福生的擦鞋店砸了。邱福生赶忙求和，不料管利鸿放下狠话，“不给钱就杀了你们”。

庭审开始于人群静默、脚镣哗哗作响的那刻。被羁押9个月的擦鞋店店主邱福生踏上被告席时，棕色棉拖鞋突然掉了，转身找鞋的一瞬，向旁听席亮出一副苍白面孔。

妻子杨丽双手掩面大哭。“他起码瘦了30斤”，出事后她一直没机会见到丈夫。去年夏天邱福生去派出所自首后，就再没回家。

庭审再现了血案细节:地点“邱峰两口子擦鞋店”，时间2008年6月17日。

邱福生原名邱峰，13年前从辽宁农村来沈阳擦鞋谋生。从一元一双擦皮鞋开始入行，攒了11年的钱，赶在2007年冬天前租了门面开了擦鞋店。

警方调查显示，被邱福生乱刀砍死的管利鸿40岁，人称鸿哥的他是鞋店的常客，频繁出没在沈阳五爱市场附近的“温州一条街”。就在出事前一个月，为离开戒毒所，管利鸿吞下饭勺，抢救过程中被意外检出是艾滋病人。

血案发生的6月，走出戒毒所再次高调出现在“温州一条街”的鸿哥，在一家饭馆吃饭“吃坏了肚子”，开价2000元，成功索赔1000元；此前在一家发廊，他开价3000元，成功索赔1500元，理由是”头皮化脓”。

并非所有的索赔都得偿所愿。另有司法材料显示，早在2002年，他因涉嫌敲诈2.8万元被刑拘。

接受法庭调查时，邱福生说他早就认识“鸿哥”，以往擦鞋不敢收费。但夜里守摊的小工王凯不认识他，去年6月16日晚上9点多，鸿哥黑白相间的运动鞋伸过来时，王凯向他要5元擦鞋费，遂遭鸿哥“索赔”。

彼时沈阳《华商晨报》以“擦错鞋油……错得要命”报道了这起索赔事件。第一次登上报纸的管利鸿是这样索赔的:他从身上抽出甩棍抽向王凯的背和头，以及店门、玻璃、鞋架子、修鞋机。“能砸的都砸了。连打带骂，开价5000元。”王凯回忆。

店主邱福生赶回被砸的小店顾不上心疼，赶忙求和，不料管利鸿放下狠话，“不给钱就杀了你们”。邱就报警，管被警察带走了。

在王凯去医院治伤的路上，邱福生接到警方的电话:“管利鸿有艾滋病，你们的医药费可能要不回来了。”

“交互传染怎么办？”

凭着有艾滋病，管利鸿拿着菜刀追民警，被追杀的民警最终破窗而出，子弹上膛，对准管利鸿，他才终于停住。

擦鞋店离它所属的滨河派出所只100米，砸店伤人在先的管利鸿却未被拘留。

司法材料显示，当晚被带到派出所后，管利鸿高调亮出自己的艾滋病患者身份。派出所向家属和沈阳市戒毒所核实的当口，他冲向所里的厨房，抄起菜刀和勺子，大叫着追值班民警。

“我赶到派出所时，他正拎着刀四处追民警”，邱福生回忆，他很快躲到对面一个胡同里，看到刚到派出所的小工王凯肩胛骨挨了管利鸿一刀。

被追杀的民警最终破窗而出，子弹上膛，打开保险，对准管利鸿。他终于停住了。按照派出所提供的《情况说明》:“由于该人患有艾滋病，民警没有对其采取强制措施，该人将菜刀、饭勺扔到派出所门前空地后逃跑。”

派出所一位民警用“史无前例”来形容当晚情形。按照他的说法，这是该所第一起涉艾案，也是民警第一次在所内被追杀。“患者拿着菜刀，一旦发生流血冲突，交互传染怎么办？”另一不愿具名的民警称:“全辽宁没有一个专关艾滋病人的地方。”

姐姐管利萍也不了解管利鸿何时感染了艾滋病，何时开始吸毒。她说，身高1米8的弟弟在家中排行老末，原本是见到父母就一把抱过来亲啊亲啊的孝子，但“吸毒后的管利鸿整个人都变了”。

本报记者获知，2004年管利鸿被沈阳市公安局列入重点人口档案，曾于1998年和2003年两次被强制戒毒。重点人口档案每个季度的追踪栏中，大多写有“居无定所”、“无法找到”的字样。对此管利萍说，“就住在5005厂附近，很好找”。

2008年6月17日，也就是管利鸿抓了又被放的第二天，滨河派出所到沈阳市疾控中心调取管利鸿的化验报告，并打听到抚顺有一家专门管理传染病人的地方。

也正是这天，命案发生了。

“我要是不干死他，就是他干死我”

管利鸿对着机器又一番乱砸，开价从5000涨到了6500，嘴中念念有词:“还敢报警，看我不弄死你。”

这天上午9点多，永盛建材店老板刘国棋来到店里，看到隔壁两口子擦鞋店外边都是玻璃，指头粗的钢筋都弯了，“邱福生说昨晚店给别人砸了，张罗着装玻璃，修机器”。

管利鸿阴沉着脸来到永盛建材店，先要买一个15元的大锤子，但后来改变主意，买了一把8块钱的刨锛，转身走向擦鞋店。

根据多位目击者的证词，管利鸿和另一个人是开车过来的，到擦鞋店后踹门而入，对着机器又一番乱砸，开价从5000涨到了6500，嘴中念念有词:“还敢报警，看我不弄死你。”

邱福生怕了，事实上这个上午他已经从银行取了1000元，这是小店半个多月的收入。他先是吓跑了，一番权衡之后，决定破财免灾。然而钱包里的钱远不能满足已经被激怒的管利鸿。

根据事发当日邱福生的证词，“管利鸿举起刀要砍我，我听说他有艾滋病，怕他传染给我，一下冲上前把刀夺下来”，但管利鸿抱住他，不让他跑。

“管利鸿喊外面的人弄死我”。情急之下无法挣脱，邱福生闭上眼睛，对着管利鸿一顿乱砍，“我当时蒙了，直到他撒开手”。

砍杀发生在不足20平米的修鞋店里，不足5分钟且缺乏目击者。邱当庭说，他被逼入角落时，管利鸿死抓着他还反抢菜刀，“砍剁出自本能，当时我要是不干死他，就是他干死我”。

9个月后再次面对血案，对死者家人来说仍是残忍的。其78岁的父亲已长病不起，左眼几乎失明。

谁是真正的受害者

检方人员竟也当庭表达了对杀人者邱福生的同情。艾滋病患者施暴在先，且邱福生属于自首，已是控辩双方的共识。

24刀对管利鸿亲属来说残忍到无法接受。管家的代理人、辽宁通顺律师事务所鲁尚杰提请法院注意，认为管利鸿有被谋杀的可能。管利萍说她对正当防卫的理解是:“3刀都可以接受，24刀太狠了！”

辩护律师孙洪文当庭回应，老实巴交的邱福生缺乏打斗经验，“为什么一个温和善良、老实巴交甚至忍气吞声的老百姓会砍死一名艾滋病人？这里有多少的被逼无奈？”

庭审前，印满二百多个猩红手印和身份证复印件、联系方式的街坊联名请愿，被提交法院。事发地沈阳的多家媒体关注修鞋匠邱福生的命运，有电视台做出总结称，邱福生是“好朋友、好邻居、好丈夫、好亲戚”。

质证双方控辩的焦点在于是否防卫过当。检方认定邱福生确实夺刀，因而具有防卫性质，但夺下刀后危险已告解除。被告律师则认为邱福生正当防卫，杀人无罪，理应无罪释放。

出乎媒体预料，检方人员竟也当庭表达了对杀人者邱福生的同情。艾滋病患者施暴在先，且邱福生属于自首，已是控辩双方的共识。

一把菜刀装在透明塑料袋里当庭展示，它的来源仍旧不明。有人看见管利鸿曾到理发店、烟店找刀，有人说看到他最后进入鞋店时并未带刀。

但可以确定的是，那天上午腰部、手指手臂多处带伤的邱福生夺路而出，砍了管利鸿后拎着菜刀，先是打110自首，后又特意提示警察赶紧叫120抢救被他砍伤的管利鸿。警方很快告知医院伤者是艾滋病人，以防医生被传染。

此时管利鸿血葫芦一样自己走出擦鞋店后，跟身边的人说了句“先别告诉家人”，不久后被抬上救护车，后因“失血性休克合并颅骨损伤”而死亡。

另一种残忍正困扰着邱福生的妻子杨丽。开庭那天她听到丈夫说出“不是他死，就是我死”时，一直流泪。事发日她曾问过目睹邱福生自首的小工王凯，王凯说自首时的邱福生嘟嘟囔囔一直说这话。

辩护律师孙洪文更是坚持认为，邱福生是社会对艾滋病人犯罪监管不力的牺牲品，他为他的当事人做无罪辩护。接受南方周末记者采访时，这位律师表态说他的当事人才是真正的被害者。“如果派出所抓了管利鸿，司法部门对艾滋病人犯罪监管得力，后来的事情就不会发生。公安都拿他没辙，难不成派军队？”他用一系列的假设强调自己的观点。

经年以来，杭州、武汉、长沙、深圳等城市，同样被艾滋病人犯罪问题困扰，而看守所条例、《强制戒毒办法》、监狱法等均为看守所和监狱拒绝艾滋病人留下了空间，司法部门的“捉放曹”导致犯人变本加厉。

该案未当庭判决，但辽宁司法界都关注着邱福生案的结果。沈阳市公安局一位警官曾撰文称，改造艾滋病犯罪者作为一项社会工程，司法不可能承担全部，而应是“各级党委政府”一起来“抓这项工作”。

南方周末记者 朝格图 发自沈阳

"I am living with my怕谁" AIDS extortion rub people killed shoemaker
At 14:10 on March 19, 2009 WASHINGTON
Related tags: [AIDS]
Tube lee hung borrow AIDS are people of their own identity, at Kaifong 4 Medium extortion.

He did not even have poor shoemaker邱福Health also rubbed off, and repeatedly "no money, they kill a" threat. Even the police are afraid of him, afraid to KWAN him, but chasing him to run.

This makes tube lee hung no fear, threat of force at邱福Health, anti-邱福Health was knifed die away.

This is shocking Shenyang rub angry shoemaker cut case of HIV patients. The local media described as "all the victim's trial together," "matter of social justice, national AIDS Human crime attitude."

In a less than 20 square meters擦鞋店Lane, 5 minutes邱福Health and Human狂砍AIDS hung lee tube 24 knives, one was charged with voluntary manslaughter case, in the morning March 16 at Shenyang City Court Trial Division ninth trial.

The trial is coming to an end, the killer slowly Health邱福up to the family of the deceased shallow Ju一躬: "I hope you can understand."

Possession of the deceased's sister, Lee Che-hung Lee Ping tube can not understand the immediate killers, she spoke with extreme Southern Weekend reporter to express their anger: "He (if) to kill non-life for a life, we will kill him."

This is shocking Shenyang rub angry shoemaker cut case of HIV patients. The local media described as "all the victim's trial together," "matter of social justice, national AIDS Human crime attitude."

"Rubbed shoe polish mistake ... ... a fatal mistake"

Tube lee hung extortion because of fights have not been met, they hit邱福students擦鞋店. Health邱福quickly sum Unexpectedly tube lee hung tough to lay down their words, "no money to kill you."

Trial began in the crowd quiet, leg irons哗哗sound that moment. Nine detainees months邱福Health擦鞋店owner set foot on the dock, the brown cotton slippers suddenly lost, the moment turned to find shoes to the gallery showed a pair of pale faces.

Cried his wife, Yang Li掩面hands. "He lost at least 30 kg," a post she has not had a chance to see her husband. Health邱福go last summer, surrendered after the police station, on the go home any more.

Murder trial reproduced the details: the location, "Feng Qiu擦鞋店wife", the time June 17, 2008.

Health邱福formerly known as Feng Qiu, 13 years ago from rural Liaoning Shenyang Shoe to earn a living. A pair of one dollar from the beginning shoeshine entry, save the money for 11 years, in time for the winter before the 2007 rented a window opened擦鞋店.

Police investigations revealed that by邱福Health乱刀砍死's 40-year-old Lee Che-hung, known as the brother hung Shoe shop him are regular, frequent haunt love Friday in Shenyang, near the market "Wenzhou Street." Just one month before the accident, in order to leave the treatment center, Lee hung swallowing tube饭勺, rescue was accidentally detected in the course of AIDS are people.

Bloody incident occurred in June, out of an addiction treatment center once again a high profile in the "Wenzhou Street" the brother hung, restaurants to eat at a "bad stomach to eat," asking price of 2,000 yuan, 1,000 yuan a successful claim; previously at a hair salon, offer him 3000 yuan, 1,500 yuan a successful claim, on the grounds that "suppurative scalp."

Not all claims are fulfilled. Otherwise judicial Materials show that early in 2002 on suspicion of blackmail him 28,000 yuan被刑拘.

Acceptance of the court investigation, said he has long邱福Know "hung brother", in the past, dare Shoe charges. However, Shou-night stands-Gong Wang Kai did not know him last year at 21:00 on June 16, and brother hung the black and white sports shoes, stretching from the time, Wang Kai him want to charge 5 yuan Shoe was being hung brother " Claim. "

Shenyang彼时"Chinese Morning" to "rub shoe polish mistake ... ... a fatal mistake," reported the case of this Claim. Newspaper boarded the first possession of Victoria are hung such claims: he was thrown out of a stick drawn back to Kai and head, as well as shop, glass, shoes rack, shoe repair machine. "Can hit all of the hit. Even playing with verbal abuse, and offer 5,000 yuan." Wang recalled.

Health邱福back to the owner of the store can not attend to distressed smashed, quickly sum Unexpectedly tube lee hung down so hard, "no money to kill you." Qiu on the police, possession by the police away.

Wang Kai injuries at the hospital go on the road, the police received邱福Health telephone: "Pipe Lee Che-hung has AIDS, the medical expenses you probably want back."

"Cross infection how do?"

With have AIDS, tube lee hung up with a police chopper was finally hunted down broken window out of police bullets loaded, Lee Che-hung at the tube, he was finally stopped.

It belongs擦鞋店Binhe from the police station only 100 meters, smashing shop earlier wounding Lee's detention has not been hung.

Judicial Materials show that night was taken to the police station, the tube-li-hung high-profile AIDS showed their identity. Station to the families and addiction treatment center Shenyang verified when the mouth, he rushed inside the kitchen, three inside the room used a kitchen knife and spoon, the police called up on duty.

"I rushed to the police station, he was carrying a knife chasing police everywhere," Health邱福memories, soon hid him across from an alley and saw the police station upon their arrival in the scapula-Gong Wang Kai-li hung hard blow pipe.

Being hunted down finally broken window out of police bullets loaded, open the insurance, at the possession of Lee hung. He finally stopped. According to the police station to provide a "description": "because of the people suffering from AIDS, police not to take coercive measures, the person will be a kitchen knife,饭勺into the police station in front of the open space after the escape."

[1] [2]  下一页